Search portmangroup.org.uk

Close

A can of beer, with a pale blue background, an alient type character holds a gamma ray run in front of a space rock background.Over the 30 Years of the Code of Practice, industry innovations and consumer trends have continuously evolved and so with it, the Code itself.  The Code is now in its sixth edition and the guidance that sits behind it is regularly updated to support the present market.  Followers of this blog series will remember that the introduction of the Code in 1996 is often linked to the rise of alco-pops in the 90s.  Today’s case from 2015 shines a spotlight on the explosion of craft beer onto the market, the way it transformed the traditional image of canned beers and how these developments were reflected in case precedents that still have a bearing today.

By 2014 the traditional beer market saw a boom in craft beers and microbreweries and with it brought a variety of new flavours, innovative brewing techniques and unique label designs.  The first case from this wave to be considered by the Independent Complaints Panel (Panel) was Gamma Ray in 2015 which featured a fantastical space theme with skeletons in space suits firing ray guns surrounded by flying spacecraft.  The style of the artwork resembled a graphic cartoon or arcade game illustration and the can itself was a 330ml size.  Key to this case was the fact that, in 2015, cans of this size were typically used for soft drinks such as cola and lemonade, whereas beer, ale and lager were generally sold in 440ml or 500ml cans.  Traditionally, such cans were often minimalistic in design with one or two tone colour schemes, straight-line fonts and a typically mature appearance.  The complainant in this case, a member of the public, raised concerns that presenting alcohol in a colourful can the same size as a soft drink, could lead to consumer confusion and encourage young people to drink alcohol.

During the Gamma Ray investigation, the Panel discussed how the size of the can was considered novel at the time.  Novel packaging has been a recurring theme in case decisions and, over the years, examples have become incredibly varied. We have seen novel in the sense of novelty, with producers wanting to stand out from the crowd.  This has resulted in everything from sperm shaped containers to light up snow globes and gun shaped bottles. While other cases have concerned packaging that is novel because it reflects new advances in manufacturing and development. Gamma Ray was the first case at this time where the Panel had to consider the change in traditional can sizes and today, we see this reflected in the ready-to-drink category where we are seeing a rise in Tetra Paks and novel containers.  In both situations, two issues tend to arise, one being whether the packaging makes the alcoholic nature of the drink absolutely clear and the second whether the novel nature of the packaging creates or contributes to a particular appeal to under-18s.

In the case of Gamma Ray, the Panel noted prominent positive alcohol cues which they were satisfied made the alcoholic nature of the drink absolutely clear. After extensive debate regarding the illustrative design, the Panel considered that, the macabre nature of the design, muted colours and nostalgic appeal of the artwork meant that, on balance, it did not have a particular appeal to under-18s in 2015.

The Gamma Ray decision was precedent setting at a time when not just the packaging size, but also the creative design was completely novel and the category changed the visible appearance of alcohol aisles over the course of the next few years.

Support on minimising the risk of particular appeal to under-18s, is consistently one of the most requested topics in the Advisory Service. The corresponding Code rule has also attracted the most complaints since the Code was introduced in 1996. Together, these trends suggest that protecting under-18s is a shared priority for the Portman Group, the alcohol industry and members of the public.  In 2023, the Portman Group and the Independent Complaints Panel commissioned children’s marketing agency, Kids Industries, to provide insights on marketing techniques used to appeal to children and teenagers outside of the alcohol industry.  This year, Kids Industries have updated their report to provide new insights into a constantly evolving area of marketing and this will shortly lead to a new update on guidance for Code rule 3.2(h).  The guidance is due to be published soon, so watch this space for details and in the meantime do not hesitate to reach out to the Advisory Service for a quick and confidential view.

A triangle label from a beer, it is black with a picture of the Kray Twins alongside the words Dark Conspiracy.

Over the last 30 years of the Code of Practice, the majority of complaints that have been investigated by the Independent Complaints Panel (Panel) have been regarding packaging. However, it is important for producers to remember that the Code applies beyond just packaging and includes on-trade staples like pump clips. Whilst complaints about pump clips are rare, they are subject to the full Code and producers therefore need to ensure they are compliant.  Let’s look at one of these precedent setting cases from 2012, Dark Conspiracy by Ramsgate Brewery, which depicted a portrait style image of the Kray Twins.

Twins Ronnie and Reggie Kray were notorious gangsters in London’s 1960s underworld. They ran a criminal organisation known as “The Firm” and their violent crimes ultimately led to them both being sentenced to life imprisonment.  The twins’ story became the stuff of London legend, with some portraying the pair in a glamourised way as ‘gangsters with manners’ whose sharp image matched the 1960s revolutions in fashion, design and music.  The Kray brothers mingled with leading celebrities and were even photographed by acclaimed fashion photographer David Bailey. Despite their place in history, it is important to remember that Code rule 3.2(b) disallows any association with violent, aggressive or anti-social behaviour even if that type of behaviour is not being emphatically depicted in marketing.

In response to the complaint, the producers of Dark Conspiracy explained that the name and pump clip design was chosen because the Kray Twins illustrated the name perfectly, conjuring up thoughts of famous conspiracies between gangsters, the press and politicians.  Whilst the Panel acknowledged that the company had not deliberately set out to associate the drink with aggression and violence, nonetheless, the Kray Twins were by their nature intrinsically linked with such conduct. The Kray Twins and their exploits were still well known and contemporary, so consumers would make the connection between them and the level of violence they used, which was inappropriate for alcohol marketing. The Panel felt that the name ‘Dark Conspiracy’ in and of itself was not necessarily problematic, but the Panel explained that the use of the Kray Twins image had direct associations with violence and aggression and so accordingly found the pump clip in breach of Code paragraph 3.2(b).

For decades, there have been instances where criminals have gained notoriety and become infamous symbols that are often portrayed as characters that may be admired.  From Al Capone to Peaky Blinders, there will always be those that are fascinated by the darker side of humanity; however, it is important to remember that the Kray Twins were real people that caused harm to those who were affected by their crimes. As the ruling against Dark Conspiracy demonstrates, some figures are inherently linked with violence.  Their inclusion in alcohol marketing is therefore likely to be problematic, even if acts of violence are not explicitly depicted.

The Code is continuously evolving and in the sixth edition of the Code, Code rule 3.2(b) was updated to include ‘illegal behaviour’ to make clear that any association with crime, including glamourising criminal figures would be unacceptable. We have guidance that explores that change in more details, which you can read . As a reminder to those who may be considering including controversial figures in their marketing, the Advisory Service is on hand and welcomes producers to share ideas at any stage of development for a free, confidential and nonbinding view under the Code to help minimise the risk of complaint.

 

The green Spotify logo alongside the Kronenburg 1664 logoThe majority of cases that the Panel consider primarily relate to packaging. In the Code’s 30-year history this accounts for 97% of all cases.  However, there are a few cases that buck this trend and fall into lesser-known areas of the Portman Group’s remit.

In 2011 a member of the public submitted a complaint about an advert played between songs on Spotify.  At the time, a marketing agency, BBH, working for Heineken, had created a ‘slowed down’ playlist for Kronenbourg 1664 and one of the songs included was ‘Too Drunk to F*ck’ by Nouvelle Vague.

The complaint was the first time the Panel had considered internet content under a drinks producer’s control on a third-party’s website.   On the surface, the case involved a clear-cut breach of the Code for referring to a song that created a direct link to drinking to excess so not a surprising outcome.  However, it’s been included in this series for two reasons.  The first being that the case captures a very specific area of remit that the Portman Group covers rather than the Advertising Standards Authority for online content that is not an advert but is within the producer’s control on a third-party website.  Secondly, the case also involved a genuine mistake where a marketing agency had not reviewed the content of the playlist in line with stricter rules that are required for alcohol marketing and had published the playlist without Heineken’s prior review.

As part of the response to the complaint, the marketing agency explained that it had not taken sufficient care and attention when selecting the playlist of songs for an alcohol client.  As soon as the matter had been brought to Heineken’s attention after it had gone live, the song was immediately removed from the playlist and was only visible for a short amount of time.

It is admittedly rarer to see a mistake like this today where marketing sign off processes are fairly robust.  However, mistakes can always creep in when there is a longer chain of review or if a step is missed before going live so it is always one to bear in mind when working with third parties.

The Advisory Service is always willing to review any marketing within remit and can work with marketing agencies as well as directly with producers.  Quite a few marketing agencies work with the Advisory Service at a pitch stage so that they can make sure every stage of their ideas comply with responsible marketing rules.  The Portman Group also regularly runs training sessions for both producers and their marketing agencies as a great way to minimise risk at every stage of the development process.

A row of 5 test tubes filled with brightly coloured liquid, the tubes have resealable lids and say the word 'Shootaz' down the side.Shot-based products have featured in several memorable moments over the 30 years of the Code of Practice.  The term ‘shot’ can be taken to imply a small measure of drink rather than a particular style of consumption, but terms like ‘shooter’ or ‘slammer’ undoubtedly carry more risk of suggesting a rapid or ‘down in one’ approach.  The Independent Complaints Panel will approach each product on a case-by-case basis and they monitor changes in consumer behaviours and attitudes to keep up to date as packaging developments evolve.

In 2009 the Panel made decisions that indicated a drink in a test-tube container would inevitably breach the Code for urging ‘down-in-one’ consumption (see 2009 decisions on Rampant and Mmwah!).  The following year, in 2010 with Shootaz, the Panel asked the Portman Group to commission independent research into the way in which consumers tended to drink products in test-tube containers and their perceptions of such products.  In light of the fresh arguments and evidence that had been made available and considering the relatively small quantity of alcohol contained in each re-sealable test-tube (0.3 of a unit), the Panel considered that the Shootaz product was unlikely to cause harmful drinking behaviour and did not breach the spirit of the Code in terms of urging ’down-in-one’ consumption.  The Panel did however note, that one of the variants in the Shootaz range was described as “Energy flavour”.  It considered that this implied that the product could enhance mental or physical performance and accordingly found the product in breach of Code paragraph 3.2(j).

Whilst resealable test tube containers are not likely to cause a problem in and of themselves, there are risks associated with messaging that suggests a rapid style of consumption. To minimise the risk of complaint, producers should ensure that shot based products promote a sip and savour style of consumption and this extends to the on-trade too, with producer led point-of-sale marketing.  As an example, the Advisory Service recommend that serving accessories such as branded trays which hold a round of shot glasses are promoted with a serving suggestion to ‘sip and savour the taste’ rather than ‘shoot’ or ‘slam’ the drink.

The Advisory Service is always on hand to provide free and confidential advice and aim to respond to all requests within 48 hours. You could say, as quick as a shot!

 

A black plastic cauldron with the words WKD Cocktail Cauldron written in bold letters on the front.In the Advisory Service we see a lot of season specific packaging and promotions intended for both the on-trade and the off-trade. While unique seasonal products can be a great way to engage with consumers, it is important to remember that on-trade promotions are captured by the Code and need to be compliant even if they are only intended to run for a short time. Let’s look at a case from 2014 which is an interesting example of the Code being applied to seasonal on-trade, producer led activity which involved a WKD drink served in a small plastic cauldron with ice and straws.

The Independent Complaints Panel (Panel) considered the promotion under Code rule 3.2(f) which disallows illegal, irresponsible or immoderate consumption. In the Advisory Service we see a lot of consideration around the number of units in a drink, particularly one that is part of a promotional offer, to ensure that the drink does not encourage immoderate consumption. This was the case here, the cauldron itself had around 3-4 units of alcohol per serve which was in line with previous CMO daily drinking guidelines. Additionally, the accompanying marketing featured a ‘made for sharing’ message. However, it is important to remember that it is not just immoderate consumption that the Code disallows but irresponsible consumption as well.

Marketing can indirectly encourage irresponsible consumption in a number of ways but that does not always involve a consumer drinking excessively. In this case, the Panel was concerned that a consumer may not know how much they had consumed when drinking directly from the vessel even if that was not an immoderate amount. The Panel considered that it would be difficult to know, when consuming the cocktail from the cauldron with a straw, how much alcohol a person had drank. When assessing the container, the Panel noted that the cauldron had nothing which suggested the drink should be decanted and was not served with glasses so that a person could measure out a serve.  The Panel acknowledged that the drink did have a share message on the accompanying materials, but it was not particularly prominent and was not on the cauldron itself. Therefore, the Panel considered that the promotional activity did encourage irresponsible consumption but welcomed that the producer had already made positive changes to the address the concerns raised.

A key learning point from this case is that novel serving vessels are not necessarily an issue under the Code, but it is important that consumers can be sure of how much they’ve had to drink, if the drink is intended to be shared. The Advisory Service regularly provides advice regarding on-trade promotions, supporting producers to ensure that promotional activities and point of sale materials are responsible.  Top tips include making sure that jugs are served with glasses, not just straws and communicating share messaging through text and visual cues such as by including a pouring lip on novel containers.

To quote Shakespeare, “Double, double toil and trouble; fire burn and cauldron bubble”.  Producers can avoid trouble by getting in touch with the Advisory Service for a quick, free and confidential view on marketing under the Codes.

A side view and front on view of a largely yellow ice-cream van named Liquor Whip and the number 99 in bold above the hatch opening.A complaint against a promotional activity featuring an ice-cream van distributing different flavours of ’99 liqueurs’ has been upheld by the alcohol industry’s Independent Complaints Panel (Panel). The full decision can be found here.

The complainant was also concerned that the packaging of the 99 liqueur shots had a particular appeal to under-18s, however this was not upheld. The full decisions can be read here.

The Panel considered the promotional activity and the product’s packaging separately under Code rule 3.2(h), which states that a drink, its packaging and any promotional activity should not have a particular appeal to under-18s.

The vehicle was designed to look like a traditional ice-cream van serving ice-cream infused with a ‘99 liqueur shot’.

The Panel considered that whilst the promotional activity took place at sites in Birmingham that were part of a university campus, this was still visible to members of the public in Birmingham city centre including under-18s. Therefore, the Panel reminded producers that age gating a promotional activity did not mean that it would not have the capacity to appeal to children who could see it, even if they could not participate.

The Panel noted the general appearance of the van including the primary colour, yellow, the use of the term ‘99’ on all sides, the large novelty ice-cream, contrasting colours, visual menu panel, sticker-style artwork and text and images with thick, bold keylines. The Panel considered that these elements could all enhance the appeal that the activity would have to under-18s who would find primary colours, contrasting colours, bold key lines and sticker-like images enticing. The Panel stated that while ice-cream in broad terms would have appeal to all ages, an ice-cream van remained a popular staple of current childhood. Taking all this into account, the Panel found that the promotional activity would have a particular appeal to under-18s and the complaint was upheld.

The Panel also considered the complaint against the six flavour variants of ‘99 liqueur’. The Panel assessed the labels individually and noted that the packaging itself made no reference to ice‑cream. They also observed that the miniature 50ml bottle format was commonly associated with alcoholic drinks. While the packaging of each variant did have a fruit flavour, a simple illustration of fruit, some black key lines and colourful text which would have a level of appeal to children, the Panel concluded that the overall impression conveyed did not create a particular appeal to under‑18s. Accordingly, the complaint was not upheld.

Chair of the Independent Complaints Panel, Rachel Childs, said: “Using nostalgic references in a promotional activity is not an automatic breach of the Code. However, producers must be cautious not to including anything which remains popular with children today. It is wholly inappropriate to link any alcoholic drink with childhood even in circumstances where age verification is in place. I would also remind producers that the inclusion of an ‘18+’ logo does not, on its own, counteract the particular appeal that a promotional activity, or packaging, can have as it is the overall impression conveyed which will determine compliance with the Code. The Panel welcomes the producer’s assurance that the ice-cream van promotional activity will not be used again.”

A spokesperson from Sazerac said: “Sazerac strives to adhere to ethical, moral, and legal standards with our portfolio of brands. We welcome Portman Group’s dismissal of allegations concerning the 99 Brand packaging.

“Our promotional 99 Brand Whip Ice Cream activation was designed to reflect 99 Brand’s personality – flavourful, fun, colourful, and creative. 99 Brand is an adult product, marketed exclusively to adults. In line with that, participation was strictly restricted to adults.

“Sazerac is committed to marketing our brands responsibly and promoting responsible consumption strictly for legal-age customers.”

A small 50ml bottle miniature bottle of a dark pink liquid and the name 99 Strawberries on the front label.Producer

Sazerac UK Limited

Complaint

“I am writing to complain about the packaging and promotional activity for “99 Liqueur” shots, a 50ml alcoholic product at 15% ABV retailing at 99p, produced by Sazerac and launched in the UK in May 2026.

I believe the product, in both its packaging and its promotional campaign, has a particular appeal to under-18s, in breach of Code paragraph 3.2(h). My concern is not with any single element in isolation but with the cumulative effect of several deliberate choices that together create a product whose overall impression is strongly likely to appeal to children and young people under 18.

Packaging design and flavour names that directly replicate children’s sweets

The overall visual identity of the packaging bears a striking resemblance to children’s confectionery rather than adult alcoholic products. Each bottle in the range uses a distinct, saturated primary or secondary colour: vivid green for Apple, bright blue for Blue Raspberry, yellow for Banana, red for Blackcherry, with the liquid inside colour-matched to reinforce the effect. Displayed together, the range presents as a rainbow of colours closely resembling a pick-and-mix sweet display. The flavour names are rendered in large, capitalised lettering in a bold, chunky, rounded typeface – a font style strongly and specifically associated with children’s sweets and toy packaging rather than adult beverages. Several labels also feature small, cartoon-style fruit illustrations. The cumulative visual effect of the colour palette, font style, cartoon imagery and colour-matched liquid is a packaging identity whose overall impression directly replicates the aesthetic of children’s confectionery. 

The flavour names themselves compound this. Blue Raspberry, Cherry, Apple, Banana, Strawberry and Pink Lemonade are not profiles associated with adult alcoholic beverages; they are the flavour palette of penny sweets and children’s soft drinks. Blue Raspberry in particular has no real-world fruit equivalent and is almost exclusively found in confectionery and children’s products. This is corroborated by independent press coverage – The Times (May 2026) described one flavour as tasting like Haribo, a children’s sweet brand, suggesting the flavour profile is not merely “broadly appealing” but specifically replicates the taste of products primarily consumed by children.

Taken together, the visual design and flavour identity combine to create packaging whose overall impression is strongly and unmistakably reminiscent of children’s sweets and confectionery.

The “99” name and branding

The product name “99” is inseparable from its ice cream van context. It does not carry an adult cultural reference in the way that, say, “1664” or “Jack Daniel’s” might. Its primary cultural resonance in the UK is a children’s treat. Combined with the activation, the name compounds rather than mitigates the appeal to under-18s.

Price point as a contributing factor

While I note that price alone does not determine whether a product has particular appeal to under-18s, at 99p this product is priced within the range of pocket money purchases. When combined with the above factors, the price point contributes to an overall impression that is accessible to and designed for younger consumers who may have limited funds.

Professional and expert opinion

These concerns are corroborated by professionals and recognised experts with direct experience of the teenagers most at risk, as follows:

Cathy Walker, an education and parenting consultant with more than 20 years’ experience working in schools, said: “These products have been designed in a way that will inevitably appeal to kids with bright colours and a super cheap price tag.” (The Times, May 15)

Harriet Rye, mental health lead at Calderstones School, one of the largest secondary schools in Liverpool, observed: “Those bottles look incredibly enticing, and at pocket money prices. Just the kind of thing that would appeal to the teens I work with.” (The Times, May 15). Ms Rye’s observation is particularly significant as it reflects frontline professional experience of how this product lands with actual secondary school-age teenagers.  

Jem Roberts, head of external affairs at the Institute of Alcohol Studies, described the launch as looking “like a product entirely designed to appeal to children while hiding behind a thin ‘nostalgia’ label”, adding: “Sweet flavours, TikTok-style branding, and even an ice-cream van — it’s hardly subtle.” His characterisation of the nostalgia framing as thin is directly relevant to the likely defence Sazerac will advance, and reflects the view of an independent research body that the cumulative effect of these design choices is not accidental. (The Guardian, May 24)

Joe Marley, executive director at Alcohol Change UK, noted that Sazerac has “a track record of going further than others when creating and marketing strong alcohol that tastes like sweets for pocket money prices, using playful approaches, bright colours and cultural trends to embed alcohol in young people’s lives.” He also raised concern about “colourful advertisements in high footfall public spaces such as bus stops and high streets” that risk appealing to children – a dimension of the marketing beyond the campus activation that the Panel may wish to consider. (The Guardian, May 24)”.

Complainant

Member of the public

Decision

Under Code paragraph 3.2(h)

A drink, its packaging and any promotional material or activity should not in any direct or indirect way have a particular appeal to under-18s.

NOT UPHELd

The company’s submission

The company explained that 99 was a heritage brand which was well established in the US market and was designed to meet the demand of an adult demographic who were attracted to affordable, single-serve products for social occasions. The company did not agree that any element of the packaging had a particular appeal to under-18s, in isolation or as part of a cumulative overall impression and stated that it had never received any previous complaints that the product would appeal to under-18s.

The company stated that it was part of a family-owned business with 400 years of experience. The business operated on strong cultural foundations of integrity, trust, ethics and values and as a responsible producer, it sought to comply with all legal and regulatory requirements in the market. The company explained that the 99 brand was launched 30 years ago in the US as ‘99 Bananas’ and had established itself as a popular liqueur and shot brand which had expanded to more than 30 flavours. The company explained that the name referred to the alcoholic strength of the US product which was ’99 proof’ and while the UK version was not of that alcoholic strength, the brand retained the ‘99’ name as an established identity. The company clarified that while the recommended retail price (RRP) was 99p it was not the source of the brand name and shared retail examples where the product was retailed higher than the RRP between £1 and £2. The drink was launched in the UK in 2026 as a full flavour shot with a 15% alcoholic strength by volume (ABV) and was marketed as a convenience product for adults.

The company stated that the drink was easily identifiable as an adult beverage in a 50ml bottle which was a widely recognised format for ‘miniature’ alcoholic drinks. The bottle was not novel and clearly stated it was an alcoholic drink in plain font with numerous positive alcohol cues on the front and back label. The text was designed to factually describe the flavour and alcoholic content of the drink, did not include onomatopoeic phrases and was displayed in black to ensure clarity and readability.  The company highlighted that the colours used on the packaging and liquid matched the corresponding flavour so that consumers could easily identify the flavour of the drink. The company stated that the use of colour in that way would not have a particular appeal to under-18s as it was commonplace to match the colour of the drink to its flavour. Additional complimentary colours were used on the packaging that were muted and pastel which the company stated aligned with Portman Group 3.2(h) guidance as having a ‘lesser appeal’ to under-18s. In addition to this, the colours used on the product were applied uniformly with no luminance, sparkle or glitter effect.

The company stated that fruit flavours had broad appeal to all ages and noted that Portman Group guidance and previous Panel precedent confirmed this position. The company reiterated that the flavours were not named after any confectionary item or well-known sweets and a generic fruit flavour could not be said to have a particular appeal to under-18s. company stated that if the drink was found to have a particular appeal on that basis, many products on the market would be unacceptable.

The company explained that there was no intended link between the drink’s name and ice cream. There was no reference to, or images of, ice cream on the packaging and the flavour was not representative of typical ice cream. While the company did not believe a consumer would link the packaging with ice cream, it noted that the Panel had stated in other precedent cases that ice cream appealed to all age groups.

The company stated that taking the above elements together, there was no basis to conclude that a single element, or the overall impression conveyed by the drink, had a particular appeal to under-18s.

The Panel’s assessment

3.2(h)

The Chair of the Panel clarified the remit of the Naming, Packaging and Promotion of Alcoholic Drinks Code (Code) and explained that the Panel’s decision would only relate to the individual packaging of the drink subject to complaint. The Code did not seek to regulate the price of alcoholic drinks nor the liquid content and therefore the Panel would not consider these elements of the complaint. The Chair also explained that the Panel would consider each flavoured drink on its own merits and not the entire range together as they were sold separately to the consumer.

The Panel considered whether the packaging of 99 Strawberries had a particular appeal to under-18s as raised by the complainant. The Panel assessed the packaging which was a 50ml plastic bottle with a long neck and screw cap. The Panel considered that the shape and size of the bottle were in keeping with traditional miniature, single serve containers for alcohol that consumers would recognise. The Panel noted that the packaging did not bear resemblance to packaging that was used for soft drinks, nor did it resemble a style of packaging that was typically aimed at under-18s. The Panel considered that the average UK consumer would most likely recognise the packaging as a traditional alcoholic miniature and that, when considered in isolation as the drink was sold, did not create an inherent link with confectionary or a soft drink.

The Panel considered the overall impression conveyed by the rest of the bottle and discussed the producer’s response which stated that the colour palette for each individual variant reflected the drink’s flavour. The Panel noted that the bright red colour of the liquid was replicated on the front label to align with the product flavour, which in this case was strawberry. The Panel considered the front label in the context of accompanying Portman Group guidance to Code rule 3.2(h) which detailed design elements often used in marketing to appeal to under-18s. In this case, the Panel noted that there were some elements which were likely to create a level of appeal to children such as black keylines used around the flavour font and chunky-style text which had multi-coloured infilled letters that were presented in a simplified style. The Panel considered that such elements were designed to make the text eye-catching and playful but in the wider context of the label represented a small amount of additional colour used outside of the fairly limited red, black and white palette. While the flavour font depicting the word ‘strawberries’ was the largest used on the front label, it was presented with straight-lined and level text. The Panel considered the presentation of the text at length, while noting that it was straight-lined, three of the infilled colours were repeated to create an eye-catching pattern and had a high level of colour contrast. The Panel discussed the pattern and colour contrast and considered that it would appeal to under-18s to an extent as it was simplistic in design and naturally eye-catching.

The Panel then considered the ‘99’ brand name which was depicted with white, black and multi-coloured keylines. The Panel noted that the text inside was black which also contributed to the simplistic nature of design. The Panel discussed the threshold of particular appeal, and the requirement that a design must resonate with under-18s in a way that it does not with adults and considered that while the presentation of the font and colour palette would be attractive to under-18s, it did not create a particular appeal to under-18s above and beyond what would also appeal to an adult.

Alongside the colour palette and font, the Panel discussed the fruit flavour theme as this was the dominant feature of the product. The Panel noted the two-dimensional illustration of a strawberry which further communicated the drink’s flavour and while the design was simple, it was not cartoon-like nor did it have a thick key line and instead used a shadow to provide a distinction with the background.  The Panel considered that while fruit flavours would have a level of appeal to children because they were sweet, an ‘strawberry’ flavour would have a broad appeal across all age groups as a well-recognised fruit. The Panel assessed the fruit presentation in the context of the rest of the label and noted that there were no other elements which may have appeal to under-18s such as anthropomorphic characters, cartoon drawings, onomatopoeic words, or other highly contrasting colours, outside of the flavour text.

With that in mind, the Panel discussed whether the name ‘99’ created an association with ice-cream as raised by the complainant. The Panel discussed the term ‘99’ in the context of ice-cream and noted that it referred to a classic British frozen treat which consisted of vanilla soft serve ice-cream in a cone with a chocolate flake garnish.  The Panel considered that the term ‘99’ also had other meanings and noted the producer’s response which linked the name to the product’s original American strength ’99 proof’ and the recommended retail price point. The Panel considered the name in the context of the packaging and noted there was nothing on the label which referred to ice-cream either in text or imagery. The Panel acknowledged that the design of the product focused on the ‘strawberry’ flavour which was not a flavour typically associated with a ‘99’ ice-cream. When discussing the overall impression of the product, the Panel considered that the strawberry flavour would be more readily associated with fruit and the majority red colour palette compounded that link, as opposed to creating an association with ice-cream which was white and beige. The Panel discussed related precedent under the Code that had been shared as part of the case and discussed the broad point that ice-cream could have a particular appeal to under-18s in some instances depending on the type and presentation, but as a generic theme was more likely to hold a wider appeal. Regardless, in this particular case, the Panel concluded that despite the reference to ‘99’, the packaging did not create any association with ice-cream and therefore could not be considered a factor that contributed to the potential appeal the drink had to under-18s.

The Panel considered the overall impression conveyed by the product and the cumulative effect of the traditional miniature 50ml bottle, fruit flavour, simple strawberry image, black key lines and thick patterned, contrast colour text. The Panel considered that while the presentation of the packaging would have a level of appeal to children, particularly the contrast colours used in the font, the overall impression conveyed did not reach the threshold to create a particular appeal to under-18s. Accordingly, the complaint was not upheld.

Action by Company

None required.

 

 

 

A side view and front on view of a largely yellow ice-cream van named Liquor Whip and the number 99 in bold above the hatch opening.

Producer

Sazerac UK Limited

Complaint

“The product was launched in part through a travelling ice cream van called the “99 Liquor Whip”, painted in the yellow, red, white and blue colour scheme of a traditional UK ice cream van and bearing a large ice cream cone on the roof, unmistakably evoking childhood. The van dispensed soft-serve ice cream infused with the shots. The name “99” directly evokes a “99 Flake” ice cream, one of the most culturally recognisable symbols of British childhood. The van’s side panels featured sticker-style graphics including cartoon eyes and dots and the kind of cluttered, playful visual language found on children’s stationery and sweet packaging.

The use of an ice cream van as a vehicle for marketing an alcoholic product is not, as Sazerac has claimed, a “nostalgia” reference aimed at adults; it is a direct appeal to imagery and associations that are, first and foremost, childhood associations. The Portman Group’s own guidance notes that packaging and promotions that mimic or reference products primarily associated with children are likely to be in breach of 3.2(h). This activation goes further than packaging; it physically replicates a childhood product experience as an introduction to an alcoholic one.

Tellingly, the van displayed signage reading “SHOTS 18+ ONLY”. The fact that Sazerac felt it necessary to add an explicit age disclaimer to what was presented as an ice cream van experience is an implicit acknowledgement that the format would otherwise be ambiguous about its intended audience and that the risk of appeal to under-18s was recognised by the company itself.

The 99 name and branding

The product name “99” is inseparable from its ice cream van context. It does not carry an adult cultural reference in the way that, say, “1664” or “Jack Daniel’s” might. Its primary cultural resonance in the UK is a children’s treat. Combined with the activation, the name compounds rather than mitigates the appeal to under-18s.

Professional and expert opinion

These concerns are corroborated by professionals and recognised experts with direct experience of the teenagers most at risk, as follows:

Cathy Walker, an education and parenting consultant with more than 20 years’ experience working in schools, said: “These products have been designed in a way that will inevitably appeal to kids with bright colours and a super cheap price tag.” (The Times, May 15)

Harriet Rye, mental health lead at Calderstones School, one of the largest secondary schools in Liverpool, observed: “Those bottles look incredibly enticing, and at pocket money prices. Just the kind of thing that would appeal to the teens I work with.” (The Times, May 15). Ms Rye’s observation is particularly significant as it reflects frontline professional experience of how this product lands with actual secondary school-age teenagers.

Jem Roberts, head of external affairs at the Institute of Alcohol Studies, described the launch as looking “like a product entirely designed to appeal to children while hiding behind a thin ‘nostalgia’ label”, adding: “Sweet flavours, TikTok-style branding, and even an ice-cream van — it’s hardly subtle.” His characterisation of the nostalgia framing as thin is directly relevant to the likely defence Sazerac will advance, and reflects the view of an independent research body that the cumulative effect of these design choices is not accidental. (The Guardian, May 24)

Joe Marley, executive director at Alcohol Change UK, noted that Sazerac has “a track record of going further than others when creating and marketing strong alcohol that tastes like sweets for pocket money prices, using playful approaches, bright colours and cultural trends to embed alcohol in young people’s lives.” He also raised concern about “colourful advertisements in high footfall public spaces such as bus stops and high streets” that risk appealing to children – a dimension of the marketing beyond the campus activation that the Panel may wish to consider. (The Guardian, May 24)”.

Complainant

Member of the public

Decision

Under Code paragraph 3.2(h)

A drink, its packaging and any promotional material or activity should not in any direct or indirect way have a particular appeal to under-18s.

UPHELD

The company’s submission

The company stated that ‘99’ was a heritage brand which was well established in the US market and was a family-owned business with 400 years of experience.  The business operated on strong cultural foundations of integrity, trust, ethics and values and as a responsible producer it sought to comply with all legal and regulatory requirements in the market. The company explained that the ice-cream van promotional activity was a one-off event designed with an adult audience in mind and was operated at two carefully selected university sites. The company added that the design, operation and safeguarding measures ensured the event did not have a particular appeal to under-18s.

The company stated that the promotional activity was an adult-only interpretation of a traditional ice-cream van designed to appeal to late1990s and early 2000s nostalgia which was popular amongst Gen Z. The locations chosen were university sites and nearly all UK university students were over 18 and so the majority of the audience was adult. The company stated that one of the sites was near to a pub which emphasised the adult nature of the promotional activity. The company explained that the promotional activity involved serving complimentary soft serve ice-cream with 99 drink samples to be consumed on site. There were no items given away to be taken home and so were not viewed by a wider audience.

The company stated that even if the promotional activity was viewed by a wider audience it had taken steps to ensure it did not have a particular appeal to under-18s in line with Portman Group 3.2(h) guidance. The company explained that the ice-cream van had a pared back design and did not use cartoon characters as contemporary ice-cream vans would and instead the predominant imagery related to alcoholic beverages.  The company rejected that ‘emoji’ style images would appeal to under-18s and referred to previous Panel precedent which stated ‘emojis’ had broad appeal. The company explained that the event featured a performance of a 2002 hit song ‘Just the Way You Are’ by Milky which reinforced the nostalgic appeal of the event. Furthermore, the company did not believe the band or song had a particular appeal to under-18s.

The company explained that additional precautions had been undertaken to ensure that the promotional activity had an adult appeal. The ice cream van contained numerous indicators that it was dispensing alcohol and there was signage which contained positive alcohol cues and responsibility messaging. A Challenge 25 policy had been adopted for service and there were also age checks in place. Further instructions to staff had also been provided to not serve any person who appeared intoxicated. The relevant event planning application had also been granted by the governing council. The company disagreed that the precautions employed suggested that the activity would otherwise have an ambiguous target audience age. The company stated that the promotion was intended to appeal to an adult demographic and did not have a particular appeal to under-18s. Nevertheless, the company confirmed it was a singular promotional activity and had no plans to repeat it.

The Panel’s assessment

The Panel discussed whether the 99 Liqueur Ice Cream Van Promotional Activity could have a particular appeal to under-18s as raised by the complainant. The Panel noted the company’s response that the promotional activity took place at two sites that were chosen as they were part of a university campus in Birmingham, one of which was opposite a licensed premise student union pub. The Panel noted that while the location of the promotional activity formed part of the university, it was situated in Birmingham city centre. The Panel considered that it was therefore reasonable to assume that a wider audience would be exposed to the marketing which could include those under-18, regardless of whether they were able to participate. The Panel referred to accompanying guidance to Code rule 3.2(h) and reminded producers that age-gating an event did not ensure compliance as a promotional activity could still have a particular appeal to under-18s in and of itself.

The Panel assessed the promotional activity which involved an ice-cream van dispensing a soft whip ice-cream infused with a ’99 liqueur’ drink. The Panel considered that ice-cream vans were typically brightly coloured commercial vehicles which drove around neighbourhoods, or parked in a static location, to sell ice-creams which most prominently included the soft serve ‘whippy’ with a flake. The Panel discussed the presentation of a typical ice-cream van and its accompanying signal which would usually play a loud, musical tune to alert local children to its presence. The Panel considered these functions were intentional features, chosen to highly resonate with children who would find the bright colours, playful music and sweet confectionery nature of ice-cream extremely enticing. The Panel noted previous related ice-cream precedent and noted that while ice-cream in broad terms would have appeal to all ages, an ice-cream van remained a popular staple of current childhood.

The Panel then discussed the presentation of the vehicle used in the promotional activity and noted that it strongly resembled a traditional ice-cream van. The Panel noted that the vehicle was a classic transit van which was also used for traditional ice-cream vans, with ‘99’ or ‘ninety nine’ on all sides of the vehicle with large novelty ice-cream cones displayed on the front. The Panel acknowledged that ‘99’ was the name of the drink but nevertheless in the context of a soft serve ice-cream van, ‘99’ further enhanced the resemblance and link to an ice-cream van aimed at children. The Panel noted that the majority of the van was a primary colour, yellow, which had a high level of contrast against the blue star, pink and red stripes that circled the vehicle. One side of the van had a serving hatch which included images of the different flavoured drinks which were presented in a ‘menu’ style. The Panel considered that this feature increased the similarity between the promotional activity and traditional ice-cream vans which would similarly display the different menu items as visual images that were easy for children to understand. When assessing the rest of the van, the Panel noted that it included text and images which had thick bold key lines and bright colours all of which would contribute to a high level of appeal to under-18s. The Panel considered that the van also used a ‘sticker’ style artwork which included fruit, swirls, stars, crosses, lightning bolts and retro ice-cream cone artwork which was stuck on in a haphazard way and reinforced a playful and youthful tone. While the van included several references to alcohol such as ‘liquor whip’, ‘adults only’, ‘flavour shots’ and ‘18+’, the Panel considered that such messages were not enough to offset the overwhelming similarity to a traditional ice-cream van. The Panel sought to remind all producers that the inclusion of an ‘18+’ logo would not on its own counteract the particular appeal that a promotional activity, or packaging, would have when the overall impression was assessed under the Code.

The Panel noted the company’s response that the promotional activity was intended to invoke nostalgia from the late 1990s and early 2000s with the adult Gen Z demographic. However, the Panel considered that while adults may have a level of nostalgia from their own childhoods, ice-cream vans remained popular with children today and by their nature had an inherent link with childhood. The Panel stated that it was wholly inappropriate to link any alcoholic drink with childhood even in circumstances where an age-gate was in place. Taking all the points above into account, the Panel found that the promotional activity would have a particular appeal to under-18s and accordingly the complaint was upheld under Code rule 3.2(h).

Action by Company

The company confirmed it would not run the promotional activity in the same form again.

 

A small 50ml bottle miniature bottle of a pale pink liquid and the name 99 Pink Lemonade on the front label.Producer

Sazerac UK Limited

Complaint

“I am writing to complain about the packaging and promotional activity for “99 Liqueur” shots, a 50ml alcoholic product at 15% ABV retailing at 99p, produced by Sazerac and launched in the UK in May 2026.

I believe the product, in both its packaging and its promotional campaign, has a particular appeal to under-18s, in breach of Code paragraph 3.2(h). My concern is not with any single element in isolation but with the cumulative effect of several deliberate choices that together create a product whose overall impression is strongly likely to appeal to children and young people under 18.

Packaging design and flavour names that directly replicate children’s sweets

The overall visual identity of the packaging bears a striking resemblance to children’s confectionery rather than adult alcoholic products. Each bottle in the range uses a distinct, saturated primary or secondary colour: vivid green for Apple, bright blue for Blue Raspberry, yellow for Banana, red for Blackcherry, with the liquid inside colour-matched to reinforce the effect. Displayed together, the range presents as a rainbow of colours closely resembling a pick-and-mix sweet display. The flavour names are rendered in large, capitalised lettering in a bold, chunky, rounded typeface – a font style strongly and specifically associated with children’s sweets and toy packaging rather than adult beverages. Several labels also feature small, cartoon-style fruit illustrations. The cumulative visual effect of the colour palette, font style, cartoon imagery and colour-matched liquid is a packaging identity whose overall impression directly replicates the aesthetic of children’s confectionery.

The flavour names themselves compound this. Blue Raspberry, Cherry, Apple, Banana, Strawberry and Pink Lemonade are not profiles associated with adult alcoholic beverages; they are the flavour palette of penny sweets and children’s soft drinks. Blue Raspberry in particular has no real-world fruit equivalent and is almost exclusively found in confectionery and children’s products. This is corroborated by independent press coverage – The Times (May 2026) described one flavour as tasting like Haribo, a children’s sweet brand, suggesting the flavour profile is not merely “broadly appealing” but specifically replicates the taste of products primarily consumed by children.

Taken together, the visual design and flavour identity combine to create packaging whose overall impression is strongly and unmistakably reminiscent of children’s sweets and confectionery.

The “99” name and branding

The product name “99” is inseparable from its ice cream van context. It does not carry an adult cultural reference in the way that, say, “1664” or “Jack Daniel’s” might. Its primary cultural resonance in the UK is a children’s treat. Combined with the activation, the name compounds rather than mitigates the appeal to under-18s.

Price point as a contributing factor

While I note that price alone does not determine whether a product has particular appeal to under-18s, at 99p this product is priced within the range of pocket money purchases. When combined with the above factors, the price point contributes to an overall impression that is accessible to and designed for younger consumers who may have limited funds.

Professional and expert opinion

These concerns are corroborated by professionals and recognised experts with direct experience of the teenagers most at risk, as follows:

Cathy Walker, an education and parenting consultant with more than 20 years’ experience working in schools, said: “These products have been designed in a way that will inevitably appeal to kids with bright colours and a super cheap price tag.” (The Times, May 15)

Harriet Rye, mental health lead at Calderstones School, one of the largest secondary schools in Liverpool, observed: “Those bottles look incredibly enticing, and at pocket money prices. Just the kind of thing that would appeal to the teens I work with.” (The Times, May 15). Ms Rye’s observation is particularly significant as it reflects frontline professional experience of how this product lands with actual secondary school-age teenagers.

 Jem Roberts, head of external affairs at the Institute of Alcohol Studies, described the launch as looking “like a product entirely designed to appeal to children while hiding behind a thin ‘nostalgia’ label”, adding: “Sweet flavours, TikTok-style branding, and even an ice-cream van — it’s hardly subtle.” His characterisation of the nostalgia framing as thin is directly relevant to the likely defence Sazerac will advance, and reflects the view of an independent research body that the cumulative effect of these design choices is not accidental. (The Guardian, May 24)

Joe Marley, executive director at Alcohol Change UK, noted that Sazerac has “a track record of going further than others when creating and marketing strong alcohol that tastes like sweets for pocket money prices, using playful approaches, bright colours and cultural trends to embed alcohol in young people’s lives.” He also raised concern about “colourful advertisements in high footfall public spaces such as bus stops and high streets” that risk appealing to children – a dimension of the marketing beyond the campus activation that the Panel may wish to consider. (The Guardian, May 24)”.

Complainant

Member of the public

Decision

Under Code paragraph 3.2(h)

A drink, its packaging and any promotional material or activity should not in any direct or indirect way have a particular appeal to under-18s.

NOT UPHELD

The company’s submission

The company explained that 99 was a heritage brand which was well established in the US market and was designed to meet the demand of an adult demographic who were attracted to affordable, single-serve products for social occasions. The company did not agree that any element of the packaging had a particular appeal to under-18s, in isolation or as part of a cumulative overall impression and stated that it had never received any previous complaints that the product would appeal to under-18s.

The company stated that it was part of a family-owned business with 400 years of experience. The business operated on strong cultural foundations of integrity, trust, ethics and values and as a responsible producer, it sought to comply with all legal and regulatory requirements in the market. The company explained that the 99 brand was launched 30 years ago in the US as ‘99 Bananas’ and had established itself as a popular liqueur and shot brand which had expanded to more than 30 flavours. The company explained that the name referred to the alcoholic strength of the US product which was ’99 proof’ and while the UK version was not of that alcoholic strength, the brand retained the ‘99’ name as an established identity. The company clarified that while the recommended retail price (RRP) was 99p it was not the source of the brand name and shared retail examples where the product was retailed higher than the RRP between £1 and £2. The drink was launched in the UK in 2026 as a full flavour shot with a 15% alcoholic strength by volume (ABV) and was marketed as a convenience product for adults.

The company stated that the drink was easily identifiable as an adult beverage in a 50ml bottle which was a widely recognised format for ‘miniature’ alcoholic drinks. The bottle was not novel and clearly stated it was an alcoholic drink in plain font with numerous positive alcohol cues on the front and back label. The text was designed to factually describe the flavour and alcoholic content of the drink, did not include onomatopoeic phrases and was displayed in black to ensure clarity and readability.  The company highlighted that the colours used on the packaging and liquid matched the corresponding flavour so that consumers could easily identify the flavour of the drink. The company stated that the use of colour in that way would not have a particular appeal to under-18s as it was commonplace to match the colour of the drink to its flavour. Additional complimentary colours were used on the packaging that were muted and pastel which the company stated aligned with Portman Group 3.2(h) guidance as having a ‘lesser appeal’ to under-18s. In addition to this, the colours used on the product were applied uniformly with no luminance, sparkle or glitter effect.

The company stated that fruit flavours had broad appeal to all ages and noted that Portman Group guidance and previous Panel precedent confirmed this position. The company reiterated that the flavours were not named after any confectionary item or well-known sweets and a generic fruit flavour could not be said to have a particular appeal to under-18s. The company stated that if the drink was found to have a particular appeal on that basis, many products on the market would be unacceptable.

The company explained that there was no intended link between the drink’s name and ice cream. There was no reference to, or images of, ice cream on the packaging and the flavour was not representative of typical ice cream. While the company did not believe a consumer would link the packaging with ice cream, it noted that the Panel had stated in other precedent cases that ice cream appealed to all age groups.

The company stated that taking the above elements together, there was no basis to conclude that a single element, or the overall impression conveyed by the drink, had a particular appeal to under-18s.

The Panel’s assessment

3.2(h)

The Chair of the Panel clarified the remit of the Naming, Packaging and Promotion of Alcoholic Drinks Code (Code) and explained that the Panel’s decision would only relate to the individual packaging of the drink subject to complaint. The Code did not seek to regulate the price of alcoholic drinks nor the liquid content and therefore the Panel would not consider these elements of the complaint. The Chair also explained that the Panel would consider each flavoured drink on its own merits and not the entire range together as they were sold separately to the consumer.

The Panel considered whether the packaging of 99 Pink Lemonade had a particular appeal to under-18s as raised by the complainant. The Panel assessed the packaging which was a 50ml plastic bottle with a long neck and screw cap. The Panel considered that the shape and size of the bottle were in keeping with traditional miniature, single serve containers for alcohol that consumers would recognise. The Panel noted that the packaging did not bear resemblance to packaging that was used for soft drinks, nor did it resemble a style of packaging that was typically aimed at under-18s. The Panel considered that the average UK consumer would most likely recognise the packaging as a traditional alcoholic miniature and that, when considered in isolation as the drink was sold, did not create an inherent link with confectionary or a soft drink.

The Panel considered the overall impression conveyed by the rest of the bottle and discussed the producer’s response which stated that the colour palette for each individual variant reflected the drink’s flavour. The Panel noted that the pink colour of the liquid was replicated on the front label to align with the product flavour, which in this case was pink lemonade. The Panel considered the front label in the context of accompanying Portman Group guidance to Code rule 3.2(h) which detailed design elements often used in marketing to appeal to under-18s. In this case, the Panel noted that there were some elements which were likely to create a level of appeal to children such as black keylines used around the flavour font and chunky-style text which had multi-coloured infilled letters that were presented in a simplified style. The Panel considered that such elements were designed to make the text eye-catching and playful but in the wider context of the label represented a small amount of additional colour used outside of the fairly limited pink, black and white palette. While the flavour font depicting the word ‘pink lemonade’ was the largest used on the front label, it was presented with straight-lined and level text. The Panel considered the presentation of the text at length, while noting that it was straight-lined, the word ‘pink’ was presented with colours that provided a high level of contrast, while the word ‘lemonade’ only appeared in black text with a white outline. The Panel discussed the colour contrast and white outline to the black lettering and considered that it would appeal to under-18s to an extent as it was simplistic in design and naturally eye-catching.

The Panel then considered the ‘99’ brand name which was depicted with white, black and multi-coloured keylines. The Panel noted that the text inside was black which also contributed to the simplistic nature of design. The Panel discussed the threshold of particular appeal, and the requirement that a design must resonate with under-18s in a way that it does not with adults and considered that while the presentation of the font and colour palette would be attractive to under-18s, it did not create a particular appeal to under-18s above and beyond what would also appeal to an adult.

Alongside the colour palette and font, the Panel discussed the fruit flavour theme as this was the dominant feature of the product. The Panel noted the two-dimensional illustration of a lemon which further communicated the drink’s flavour and while the design was simple, it was not cartoon-like nor did it have a thick key line and instead used a shadow to provide a distinction with the background.  The Panel considered that while fruit flavours would have a level of appeal to children because they were sweet, a ‘pink lemonade’ flavour would have a broad appeal across all age groups as a well-recognised fruit. The Panel assessed the fruit presentation in the context of the rest of the label and noted that there were no other elements which may have appeal to under-18s such as anthropomorphic characters, cartoon drawings, onomatopoeic words, or other highly contrasting colours, outside of the flavour text.

With that in mind, the Panel discussed whether the name ‘99’ created an association with ice-cream as raised by the complainant. The Panel discussed the term ‘99’ in the context of ice-cream and noted that it referred to a classic British frozen treat which consisted of vanilla soft serve ice-cream in a cone with a chocolate flake garnish.  The Panel considered that the term ‘99’ also had other meanings and noted the producer’s response which linked the name to the product’s original American strength ’99 proof’ and the recommended retail price point. The Panel considered the name in the context of the packaging and noted there was nothing on the label which referred to ice-cream either in text or imagery. The Panel acknowledged that the design of the product focused on the ‘pink lemonade’ flavour which was not a flavour typically associated with a ‘99’ ice-cream. When discussing the overall impression of the product, the Panel considered that the pink lemonade flavour would be more readily associated with fruit and the majority pink colour palette compounded that link, as opposed to creating an association with ice-cream which was white and beige. The Panel discussed related precedent under the Code that had been shared as part of the case and discussed the broad point that ice-cream could have a particular appeal to under-18s in some instances depending on the type and presentation, but as a generic theme was more likely to hold a wider appeal. Regardless, in this particular case, the Panel concluded that despite the reference to ‘99’, the packaging did not create any association with ice-cream and therefore could not be considered a factor that contributed to the potential appeal the drink had to under-18s.

The Panel considered the overall impression conveyed by the product and the cumulative effect of the traditional miniature 50ml bottle, fruit flavour, simple lemon image, black key lines and thick contrast colour text. The Panel considered that while the presentation of the packaging would have a level of appeal to children, particularly the contrast colours used in the font, the overall impression conveyed did not reach the threshold to create a particular appeal to under-18s. Accordingly, the complaint was not upheld.

Action by Company

None required.

A small 50ml bottle miniature bottle of a bright yellow liquid and the name 99 Bananas on the front label.Producer

Sazerac UK Limited

 Complaint

“I am writing to complain about the packaging and promotional activity for “99 Liqueur” shots, a 50ml alcoholic product at 15% ABV retailing at 99p, produced by Sazerac and launched in the UK in May 2026.

I believe the product, in both its packaging and its promotional campaign, has a particular appeal to under-18s, in breach of Code paragraph 3.2(h). My concern is not with any single element in isolation but with the cumulative effect of several deliberate choices that together create a product whose overall impression is strongly likely to appeal to children and young people under 18.

Packaging design and flavour names that directly replicate children’s sweets

The overall visual identity of the packaging bears a striking resemblance to children’s confectionery rather than adult alcoholic products. Each bottle in the range uses a distinct, saturated primary or secondary colour: vivid green for Apple, bright blue for Blue Raspberry, yellow for Banana, red for Blackcherry, with the liquid inside colour-matched to reinforce the effect. Displayed together, the range presents as a rainbow of colours closely resembling a pick-and-mix sweet display. The flavour names are rendered in large, capitalised lettering in a bold, chunky, rounded typeface – a font style strongly and specifically associated with children’s sweets and toy packaging rather than adult beverages. Several labels also feature small, cartoon-style fruit illustrations. The cumulative visual effect of the colour palette, font style, cartoon imagery and colour-matched liquid is a packaging identity whose overall impression directly replicates the aesthetic of children’s confectionery.

The flavour names themselves compound this. Blue Raspberry, Cherry, Apple, Banana, Strawberry and Pink Lemonade are not profiles associated with adult alcoholic beverages; they are the flavour palette of penny sweets and children’s soft drinks. Blue Raspberry in particular has no real-world fruit equivalent and is almost exclusively found in confectionery and children’s products. This is corroborated by independent press coverage – The Times (May 2026) described one flavour as tasting like Haribo, a children’s sweet brand, suggesting the flavour profile is not merely “broadly appealing” but specifically replicates the taste of products primarily consumed by children.

Taken together, the visual design and flavour identity combine to create packaging whose overall impression is strongly and unmistakably reminiscent of children’s sweets and confectionery.

The “99” name and branding

The product name “99” is inseparable from its ice cream van context. It does not carry an adult cultural reference in the way that, say, “1664” or “Jack Daniel’s” might. Its primary cultural resonance in the UK is a children’s treat. Combined with the activation, the name compounds rather than mitigates the appeal to under-18s.

Price point as a contributing factor

While I note that price alone does not determine whether a product has particular appeal to under-18s, at 99p this product is priced within the range of pocket money purchases. When combined with the above factors, the price point contributes to an overall impression that is accessible to and designed for younger consumers who may have limited funds.

Professional and expert opinion

These concerns are corroborated by professionals and recognised experts with direct experience of the teenagers most at risk, as follows:

Cathy Walker, an education and parenting consultant with more than 20 years’ experience working in schools, said: “These products have been designed in a way that will inevitably appeal to kids with bright colours and a super cheap price tag.” (The Times, May 15)

Harriet Rye, mental health lead at Calderstones School, one of the largest secondary schools in Liverpool, observed: “Those bottles look incredibly enticing, and at pocket money prices. Just the kind of thing that would appeal to the teens I work with.” (The Times, May 15). Ms Rye’s observation is particularly significant as it reflects frontline professional experience of how this product lands with actual secondary school-age teenagers.

Jem Roberts, head of external affairs at the Institute of Alcohol Studies, described the launch as looking “like a product entirely designed to appeal to children while hiding behind a thin ‘nostalgia’ label”, adding: “Sweet flavours, TikTok-style branding, and even an ice-cream van — it’s hardly subtle.” His characterisation of the nostalgia framing as thin is directly relevant to the likely defence Sazerac will advance, and reflects the view of an independent research body that the cumulative effect of these design choices is not accidental. (The Guardian, May 24)

Joe Marley, executive director at Alcohol Change UK, noted that Sazerac has “a track record of going further than others when creating and marketing strong alcohol that tastes like sweets for pocket money prices, using playful approaches, bright colours and cultural trends to embed alcohol in young people’s lives.” He also raised concern about “colourful advertisements in high footfall public spaces such as bus stops and high streets” that risk appealing to children – a dimension of the marketing beyond the campus activation that the Panel may wish to consider. (The Guardian, May 24)”.

Complainant

Member of the public

Decision

Under Code paragraph 3.2(h)

A drink, its packaging and any promotional material or activity should not in any direct or indirect way have a particular appeal to under-18s.

 NOT UPHELD

The company’s submission

The company explained that 99 was a heritage brand which was well established in the US market and was designed to meet the demand of an adult demographic who were attracted to affordable, single-serve products for social occasions. The company did not agree that any element of the packaging had a particular appeal to under-18s, in isolation or as part of a cumulative overall impression and stated that it had never received any previous complaints that the product would appeal to under-18s.

The company stated that it was part of a family-owned business with 400 years of experience. The business operated on strong cultural foundations of integrity, trust, ethics and values and as a responsible producer, it sought to comply with all legal and regulatory requirements in the market. The company explained that the 99 brand was launched 30 years ago in the US as ‘99 Bananas’ and had established itself as a popular liqueur and shot brand which had expanded to more than 30 flavours. The company explained that the name referred to the alcoholic strength of the US product which was ’99 proof’ and while the UK version was not of that alcoholic strength, the brand retained the ‘99’ name as an established identity. The company clarified that while the recommended retail price (RRP) was 99p it was not the source of the brand name and shared retail examples where the product was retailed higher than the RRP between £1 and £2. The drink was launched in the UK in 2026 as a full flavour shot with a 15% alcoholic strength by volume (ABV) and was marketed as a convenience product for adults.

The company stated that the drink was easily identifiable as an adult beverage in a 50ml bottle which was a widely recognised format for ‘miniature’ alcoholic drinks. The bottle was not novel and clearly stated it was an alcoholic drink in plain font with numerous positive alcohol cues on the front and back label. The text was designed to factually describe the flavour and alcoholic content of the drink, did not include onomatopoeic phrases and was displayed in black to ensure clarity and readability.  The company highlighted that the colours used on the packaging and liquid matched the corresponding flavour so that consumers could easily identify the flavour of the drink. The company stated that the use of colour in that way would not have a particular appeal to under-18s as it was commonplace to match the colour of the drink to its flavour. Additional complimentary colours were used on the packaging that were muted and pastel which the company stated aligned with Portman Group 3.2(h) guidance as having a ‘lesser appeal’ to under-18s. In addition to this, the colours used on the product were applied uniformly with no luminance, sparkle or glitter effect.

The company stated that fruit flavours had broad appeal to all ages and noted that Portman Group guidance and previous Panel precedent confirmed this position. The company reiterated that the flavours were not named after any confectionary item or well-known sweets and a generic fruit flavour could not be said to have a particular appeal to under-18s. The company stated that if the drink was found to have a particular appeal on that basis, many products on the market would be unacceptable.

The company explained that there was no intended link between the drink’s name and ice cream. There was no reference to, or images of, ice cream on the packaging and the flavour was not representative of typical ice cream. While the company did not believe a consumer would link the packaging with ice cream, it noted that the Panel had stated in other precedent cases that ice cream appealed to all age groups.

The company stated that taking the above elements together, there was no basis to conclude that a single element, or the overall impression conveyed by the drink, had a particular appeal to under-18s.

The Panel’s assessment

3.2(h)

The Chair of the Panel clarified the remit of the Naming, Packaging and Promotion of Alcoholic Drinks Code (Code) and explained that the Panel’s decision would only relate to the individual packaging of the drink subject to complaint. The Code did not seek to regulate the price of alcoholic drinks nor the liquid content and therefore the Panel would not consider these elements of the complaint. The Chair also explained that the Panel would consider each flavoured drink on its own merits and not the entire range together as they were sold separately to the consumer.

The Panel considered whether the packaging of 99 Bananas had a particular appeal to under-18s as raised by the complainant. The Panel assessed the packaging which was a 50ml plastic bottle with a long neck and screw cap. The Panel considered that the shape and size of the bottle were in keeping with traditional miniature, single serve containers for alcohol that consumers would recognise. The Panel noted that the packaging did not bear resemblance to packaging that was used for soft drinks, nor did it resemble a style of packaging that was typically aimed at under-18s. The Panel considered that the average UK consumer would most likely recognise the packaging as a traditional alcoholic miniature and that, when considered in isolation as the drink was sold, did not create an inherent link with confectionary or a soft drink.

The Panel considered the overall impression conveyed by the rest of the bottle and discussed the producer’s response which stated that the colour palette for each individual variant reflected the drink’s flavour. The Panel noted that the bright yellow colour of the liquid was replicated on the front label to align with the product flavour, which in this case was banana. The Panel considered the front label in the context of accompanying Portman Group guidance to Code rule 3.2(h) which detailed design elements often used in marketing to appeal to under-18s. In this case, the Panel noted that there were some elements which were likely to create a level of appeal to children such as black keylines used around the flavour font and chunky-style text which had multi-coloured infilled letters that were presented in a simplified style. The Panel considered that such elements were designed to make the text eye-catching and playful but in the wider context of the label represented a small amount of additional colour used outside of the fairly limited yellow, black and white palette. While the flavour font depicting the word ‘bananas’ was the largest used on the front label, it was presented with straight-lined and level text. The Panel considered the presentation of the text at length, while noting that it was straight-lined, three of the infilled colours were repeated to create an eye-catching pattern and had a high level of colour contrast. The Panel discussed the pattern and colour contrast and considered that it would appeal to under-18s to an extent as it was simplistic in design and naturally eye-catching.

The Panel then considered the ‘99’ brand name which was depicted with white, black and multi-coloured keylines. The Panel noted that the text inside was black which also contributed to the simplistic nature of design. The Panel discussed the threshold of particular appeal, and the requirement that a design must resonate with under-18s in a way that it does not with adults and considered that while the presentation of the font and colour palette would be attractive to under-18s, it did not create a particular appeal to under-18s above and beyond what would also appeal to an adult.

Alongside the colour palette and font, the Panel discussed the fruit flavour theme as this was the dominant feature of the product. The Panel noted the two-dimensional illustration of a banana which further communicated the drink’s flavour and while the design was simple, it was not cartoon-like nor did it have a thick key line and instead used a shadow to provide a distinction with the background.  The Panel considered that while fruit flavours would have a level of appeal to children because they were sweet, a banana flavour would have a broad appeal across all age groups as a well-recognised fruit. The Panel assessed the fruit presentation in the context of the rest of the label and noted that there were no other elements which may have appeal to under-18s such as anthropomorphic characters, cartoon drawings, onomatopoeic words, or other highly contrasting colours, outside of the flavour text.

With that in mind, the Panel discussed whether the name ‘99’ created an association with ice-cream as raised by the complainant. The Panel discussed the term ‘99’ in the context of ice-cream and noted that it referred to a classic British frozen treat which consisted of vanilla soft serve ice-cream in a cone with a chocolate flake garnish.  The Panel considered that the term ‘99’ also had other meanings and noted the producer’s response which linked the name to the product’s original American strength ’99 proof’ and the recommended retail price point. The Panel considered the name in the context of the packaging and noted there was nothing on the label which referred to ice-cream either in text or imagery. The Panel acknowledged that the design of the product focused on the ‘banana’ flavour which was not a flavour typically associated with a ‘99’ ice-cream. When discussing the overall impression of the product, the Panel considered that the banana flavour would be more readily associated with fruit and the majority yellow colour palette compounded that link, as opposed to creating an association with ice-cream which was white and beige. The Panel discussed related precedent under the Code that had been shared as part of the case and discussed the broad point that ice-cream could have a particular appeal to under-18s in some instances depending on the type and presentation, but as a generic theme was more likely to hold a wider appeal. Regardless, in this particular case, the Panel concluded that despite the reference to ‘99’, the packaging did not create any association with ice-cream and therefore could not be considered a factor that contributed to the potential appeal the drink had to under-18s.

The Panel considered the overall impression conveyed by the product and the cumulative effect of the traditional miniature 50ml bottle, fruit flavour, simple banana image, black key lines and thick patterned, contrast colour text. The Panel considered that while the presentation of the packaging would have a level of appeal to children, particularly the contrast colours used in the font, the overall impression conveyed did not reach the threshold to create a particular appeal to under-18s. Accordingly, the complaint was not upheld.

Action by Company

None required.