The majority of cases that the Panel consider primarily relate to packaging. In the Code’s 30-year history this accounts for 97% of all cases. However, there are a few cases that buck this trend and fall into lesser-known areas of the Portman Group’s remit.
In 2011 a member of the public submitted a complaint about an advert played between songs on Spotify. At the time, a marketing agency, BBH, working for Heineken, had created a ‘slowed down’ playlist for Kronenbourg 1664 and one of the songs included was ‘Too Drunk to F*ck’ by Nouvelle Vague.
The complaint was the first time the Panel had considered internet content under a drinks producer’s control on a third-party’s website. On the surface, the case involved a clear-cut breach of the Code for referring to a song that created a direct link to drinking to excess so not a surprising outcome. However, it’s been included in this series for two reasons. The first being that the case captures a very specific area of remit that the Portman Group covers rather than the Advertising Standards Authority for online content that is not an advert but is within the producer’s control on a third-party website. Secondly, the case also involved a genuine mistake where a marketing agency had not reviewed the content of the playlist in line with stricter rules that are required for alcohol marketing and had published the playlist without Heineken’s prior review.
As part of the response to the complaint, the marketing agency explained that it had not taken sufficient care and attention when selecting the playlist of songs for an alcohol client. As soon as the matter had been brought to Heineken’s attention after it had gone live, the song was immediately removed from the playlist and was only visible for a short amount of time.
It is admittedly rarer to see a mistake like this today where marketing sign off processes are fairly robust. However, mistakes can always creep in when there is a longer chain of review or if a step is missed before going live so it is always one to bear in mind when working with third parties.
The Advisory Service is always willing to review any marketing within remit and can work with marketing agencies as well as directly with producers. Quite a few marketing agencies work with the Advisory Service at a pitch stage so that they can make sure every stage of their ideas comply with responsible marketing rules. The Portman Group also regularly runs training sessions for both producers and their marketing agencies as a great way to minimise risk at every stage of the development process.